Skip to main content

Woman's death in Ireland abortion case ruled 'medical misadventure'

By Peter Taggart and Laura Smith-Spark, CNN
April 19, 2013 -- Updated 1704 GMT (0104 HKT)
Protest during a march against Government austerity measures in Dublin, Ireland on November 24, 2012.
Protest during a march against Government austerity measures in Dublin, Ireland on November 24, 2012.
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Inquest jury in Galway returns verdict of death by medical misadventure
  • Savita Halappanavar, 31, died last October after suffering a miscarriage
  • Coroner offers Ireland's "deepest sympathy" to Savita's widower, Praveen
  • He says his wife's treatment in hospital was "horrendous, barbaric and inhuman"

(CNN) -- The death of an Indian dentist who died after a miscarriage in an Irish hospital was the result of medical misadventure, an inquest jury ruled Friday.

Savita Halappanavar, 31, was 17 weeks pregnant when she died in October at University Hospital Galway.

The inquest jury heard seven days of evidence from staff and expert witnesses, as well as her widower, Praveen Halappanavar.

A pathologist, Professor Grace Callagy, told the inquest the cause of death was septic shock, E. Coli in Savita Halappanavar's bloodstream and a miscarriage.

Ireland amends abortion law
Death leads to abortion rally in Ireland

In his evidence, a leading obstetrician said Halappanavar's life could have been saved had a termination been carried out a day or two before her miscarriage.

However, Dr. Peter Boylan admitted it would not have been practical under Irish law, which states there has to be a real and substantial risk to the mother's life.

The coroner, Dr. Ciaran MacLoughlin, on Friday directed jurors at Galway Coroner's Court to consider carefully the verdict and his recommendations, including that Ireland's Medical Council should lay out exactly when doctors can intervene to save the life of a mother.

The jury unanimously returned the misadventure verdict and "strongly endorsed" his recommendations.

MacLoughlin told the dentist's husband: "The whole of Ireland has followed your story and I want, on their behalf, to offer our deepest sympathy."

Outside the court, Praveen Halappanavar said he still had not got all the answers but would "get to the bottom of the truth."

Somebody has to take responsibility for his wife's death, he said.

He told reporters that the way Savita had been treated in the hospital was "horrendous, barbaric and inhuman."

Friday was particularly poignant as it would have been the couple's fifth wedding anniversary, he added.

In his evidence last week, Praveen Halappananvar said that he had been told an abortion could not be done while the fetus was still alive because Ireland is a Catholic country.

The couple were married in India before moving to Ireland, where they had lived for four years before Savita's death.

'System failures'

Giving evidence last week, consultant Dr. Katherine Astbury, who treated Halappanavar, denied saying an abortion could not be carried out "because Ireland is a Catholic country."

But she acknowledged that she felt constrained by Irish law, which does not permit a termination even if there is no prospect of the fetus surviving.

Astbury also admitted that there were "system failures" in Halappanavar's care. For example, Astbury had not been made aware of blood test abnormalities and an infection, she said.

A midwife at Galway hospital, Ann Maria Burke, apologized in her evidence for telling Halappanavar a termination would not be possible "because Ireland is a Catholic country." She said the comment was not meant to be hurtful.

Halappanavar went into the hospital on October 21, complaining of back pain. Three days after the request for a termination was made, the fetus died and was removed. Four days later, Savita died of a blood infection.

An inquest by a coroner is standard procedure in cases of sudden, unexplained or unnatural deaths in Ireland.

READ MORE: Husband testifies his wife died after abortion was denied in Ireland

READ MORE: If Ireland had abortion rights

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
May 8, 2013 -- Updated 0959 GMT (1759 HKT)
Sir Alex Ferguson retires after nearly 27 years managing Manchester United. CNN's Ben Wyatt looks at his hugely successful legacy.
May 7, 2013 -- Updated 1232 GMT (2032 HKT)
Amid the massive global interest in the release of Amanda Knox's memoir, it has been easy to overlook the victim.
May 6, 2013 -- Updated 1956 GMT (0356 HKT)
Reports that Israel conducted airstrikes in Syria is stoking new fears that the conflict could escalate, involving Iran, Israel and the West.
May 7, 2013 -- Updated 2034 GMT (0434 HKT)
Jurors hearing the Michael Jackson wrongful death trial got a stark look at the dead pop icon after a lawyer showed them an autopsy photo.
May 8, 2013 -- Updated 1001 GMT (1801 HKT)
Questions remain over who was ultimately responsible for the Bangladesh building collapse, which claimed over 700 garment worker's lives.
May 8, 2013 -- Updated 0535 GMT (1335 HKT)
Bank of China stops business with a large N. Korean bank, following U.S.-led sanctions to restrict Pyongyang's nuclear program funding.
May 7, 2013 -- Updated 1407 GMT (2207 HKT)
CNN's Zain Verjee speaks to the African Union commander in Mogadishu for the real picture on the ground in Somalia.
May 7, 2013 -- Updated 0449 GMT (1249 HKT)
CNN's Gary Tuchman looks at the dilemma: where do you bury the worst of the worst?
May 8, 2013 -- Updated 0524 GMT (1324 HKT)
Italians point to high-profile cases in which they say American suspects have been accused of criminal acts, but have been let off lightly.
May 3, 2013 -- Updated 1130 GMT (1930 HKT)
Our graphic illustrates the stark contrast in the cost of making clothes in Bangladesh, compared to the U.S.
May 7, 2013 -- Updated 1246 GMT (2046 HKT)
Pedro Matos Darfur Sartorialist 9
When Pedro Matos arrived in conflict-ridden Darfur in 2009, the last thing he expected to encounter was sartorial splendor.
May 7, 2013 -- Updated 1238 GMT (2038 HKT)
Science fiction fantasy could be turning into reality by the development of a memory device to implant into patients.
May 7, 2013 -- Updated 1011 GMT (1811 HKT)
Boeing exclusively reveals how the company dealt with the technical and logistical challenges of repairing the Dreamliner.
Artists in Asia's world city produce meticulous dioramas that capture the city's cultural highlights and residential lows.
The CNN iReport Awards celebrate journalism and reward iReporters for their contributions. Vote for your favorite until May 6.
ADVERTISEMENT